After nine years of trekking through and around the Mahoning valley in a quest to find the best burgers, we have come to the conclusion: Man, there’s a lot of great burgers around here!
The last time we published our overall MV rankings was in 2014. A lot of places have come and gone since then, and many of the places that we have visited have stepped up their burger game, so, we decided to do it again.
Four years ago, Chef Mel McKee, from Bogey’s Bar & Grill, in Lowellville, put together an awesome burger menu with so many delicious, unique toppings that we unanimously voted them in at #1. Can they hold on to the top ranking or has one of the 47 restaurants we’ve reviewed since then, unseated them? Click on the “Top 40” image at the bottom of the page to see the current top 40 burgers of the valley.
Here’s a little insight as to how we rank them;
- Our visit. The biggest factor is based on our initial visit. We have a scorecard for each burger we try. We scrutinize the beef, the bun, the toppings, sauces, and sides. Then we take into account, cleanliness, the service, and the atmosphere.
- Competitions. Entering competitions and losing will not cause a drop in the rankings, but we do factor in any awards that are won.
- Media recognition. Any awards from newspapers, magazines, or websites, such as, Best of the Best and Peoples Choice, also count.
- Revisit. We listen to all of the comments and opinions on our social media posts, good, bad, and ugly, which sometimes leads to a revisit.
So many awesome burgers, so little time! Since 2009, we have ranked all of the burgers we’ve tried that you our readers have recommended to us; close to 100 Mahoning Valley restaurants, bar & grills, taverns, pubs and diners. A very small percentage have been disappointing. Over the years, restaurants have moved up or down on our list and ones that no longer exist, obviously, have been removed. Our rankings are based primarily on our official visit but other things factor in, such as, comments from the public endorsing or criticizing, awards from any competitions, media awards, and anything else noteworthy. We do try to keep up with everything, but, occasionally we miss a closing or an award, so any assistance you can give us is much appreciated! We have overall rankings that will be published soon, but we also broke them down by county. Burgers reviewed in 2018 have not yet been ranked. We enjoyed ALL of the burgers on this list, just some more than others! Let us know how we did, or if we missed your favorite, so we can get them on the list! Click on the “Top 20” image below to view the current Mahoning County burger rankings.
TOP 5 TRUMBULL COUNTY BURGERS
#5 – Raptis Family Restaurant
On State Route 46, North of Howland Corners, this quaint, hometown restaurant has a loyal base that swears by the food. We can testify that the hearty burgers are a savory delight! Raptis is home of the Howland Tiger Burger, a favorite among patrons. Check out our review of Raptis HERE.
#4 – Sunrise Inn of Warren
Located at 510 E. Market St., in the heart of Warren, Sunrise Inn is well known for their delicious pizza and other authentic Italian dishes. But Chef Stu wants it clear that his good ole All-American burger isn’t taking a backseat to the Italian cuisine! Crafted with fresh ground steak, fresh and sometime unique toppings, and served on a crispy crust brioche style bun, it’s easy to see why they received the 2011 Burger of the Year award! Check out our review of Sunrise Inn HERE.
#3 – Peter Allen Inn
If you are looking for a little history with your meal, check out Peter Allen Inn, 8581 State St. in Kinsman. Completely restored to it’s 1820’s splendor, the historic bed and breakfast offers a surprise in the cellar – the Tavern on the Courtyard. The menu offers one burger selection that changes seasonally. Negotiating other options for toppings is possible, but after seeing the menu burger, you may not want to! The key to this burger is the fresh, high quality, grass fed beef directly from owner Richard Thompson’s Heritage Hills Farm. See the review HERE.
#2 – The Lake Tavern
Speaking of history, walking into the Lake Tavern is almost like being transported back in time. With all of the ambiance of an old West saloon, this tavern, on SR46 in Mecca holds many awards including the 2012 BOTY, several Battle of the Burgers awards, 2017 Tribune Chronicle People’s Choice Best Burger, 2013 Trib People’s Choice Best Tavern, several wing competition trophies, named by Thrillist.com as one of the top 15 burgers in Ohio… you get the picture! Literally dozens of burger choices on the menu. Check out our review of the Lake Tavern HERE.
#1 – Big D’s Newton Grill
Owner Ron Dillon has turned Big D’s into a shrine to hamburgers! His love for burgers, his talent for cooking, and his willingness to push the creativity envelope has propelled the Newton Falls restaurant to the top of the the Trumbull County burger mountain with cheeseburgers that will knock your socks off! Winner of the 2017 Meat 16 tournament as well as the 2017 BOTY, Ron is constantly experimenting in the kitchen, searching for the holy grail of burger toppings. If you are lucky enough to time your dinner right, you may be asked to be a guinea pig for one of these artistically crafted beauties! Check out the Big D’s review HERE
The Mahoning county restaurants competing in this year’s Meat 16 Cheeseburger Challenge tournament:
- Bogey’s Bar & Grill – Lowellville
- Magic Tree Pub & Eatery – Boardman
- Phoenix Fire Grill & Bar – Canfield
- Davidson’s Restaurant & Bar – Cornersberg
- Coaches Burger Bar – Poland
- The Pour House – Canfield
- Mojo’s Pub – Austintown
- Ice House Inn – Austintown
View Trumbull County entries.
Click HERE to check out what makes the Burger of the Year, Burger of the Year!
After weeks of deliberation, the selection for the BURGERGUYZ 2017 BURGER OF THE YEAR has been made! The 4 finalists, The Phoenix Fire Grill, Big D’s Newton Grill, Pondi’s Bar & Restaurant, and Peter Allen Inn are all worthy of an award, but only one can win! Click the award to reveal the winner!