MVBRB Extra: Valley Magazine article (6-3-10)

The following is an article about us published in the June/July issue of Valley Magazine. We would like to express our sincere thanks to Susan Melish and Valley Magazine for writing and printing this article. The interview, the photo shoot – it was great fun!


Local Hamburger Review Board is on
its way to finding the best of the Valley
By Susan Melish

MVBRB members, Tony Krusely, Anthony Fuda, Scott Long, and Mike Flarey

Jerry Tranovich carefully lifts the top bun of his John Wayne, a burger topped with bacon, caramelized onions and onion rings, smoked cheddar cheese and barbecue sauce. He surveys the toppings, replaces the bun and takes a big bite. An analytical expression crosses his face. “The seasoning of the beef is outstanding,” remarks Anthony Fuda, who’s undergone the same routine. “Perfect,” adds fellow diner Mike Flarey. The remaining two cohorts, Scott Long and Tony Krusely, agree, scribbling notes on score sheets in between chews.

It may look like just another night out for burgers with the boys at Martini Brothers in Girard, but for these five postal workers, it’s as much business as it is pleasure.
before, but their intention isn’t to trash.
MVBRB chairman, Jerry Tranovich

Last summer, Tranovich, co-chair of the Mahoning Valley Burger Review Board read about a group of friends ferreting out the best burger in New York City by eating their way through every restaurant in the Big Apple. That got him thinking. “We’ve got great burgers right here,” says Tranovich, recalling that he and Long, his co-chair, decided to conduct a burger challenge in the Valley. “[We] told everyone at the Niles Post Office where we work about our burger plans and invited anyone to join us. These are the guys who showed up. And we have had a blast ever since.”
Once a month for the last year, the Board has picked a local restaurant to review unannounced. They come, eat and rate each burger using an agreed upon scoring system. And they’re not afraid to “call ‘em like they eat ‘em,” Tranovich says, explaining they have given a burger a single star

“If we see where there’s room for improvement, we like to make suggestions,” he says, citing the Mahoning Valley Restaurant as having a fantastic burger that was just too small. “If their burger was twice the size, it could definitely be in the running for the 2010 Burger of the Year.”
Instead, Martini Brothers is in the top spot for this year due to its well-seasoned ground beef, a soft but sturdy Ciabatta bun and first-rate toppings.
“When this all started, no one knew it would take off like it has,” Tranovich explains. After requests they make their findings public, Fuda created a Facebook page (search for MVBRB) and MySpace account where the group’s findings are displayed for 430-plus fans. He also writes a monthly report for The Review. But the group is most excited about the unveiling of its Better Burger Club on Facebook. Become a fan and receive a BBC card, which can be presented to participating reviewed eateries for deals.
But even still, the guys of the Board do not take themselves too seriously. “This is just our opinions, but it is amazing how people like and support what we are doing. My wife doesn’t even laugh at me
anymore,” Tranovich says.

How To Rate a Burger


Each member of the Mahoning Valley Burger Review Board can score a burger out of a possible 100 points (no burger has ever been given a perfect rating). Scores are averaged into a star system. Five stars, “best burger you’ve ever had,” equals a total of 96 or higher. Whereas
anything below 55 points garners a mere half star, meaning “go somewhere else.”
Beef counts for 40 points. Buns and toppings can each earn 20. Side dishes and overall presentation each earn 10. Outside factors count, too, including service, cost of the burger, atmosphere and cleanliness. Each can add to, or subtract from, the total score 1, 2 or 3 points.
“Judging burgers is not rocket science, but people are beginning to listen to our opinions and we take that seriously,” Fuda says.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s